The Obsidian Library
A safe space for spoilers. Finish the book, then come talk about it.
Latest Reviews
All reviews →- Fantasy
The Will of the Many
- Contemporary & Historical Fiction
Spectacular Things
- Fantasy
An Echo of Things to Come
- Contemporary & Historical Fiction
Yesteryear
- Mystery / Thriller
The Keeper
- Contemporary
Into the Blue
- Romantasy
Brimstone
- Mystery / Thriller
First Lie Wins
- Romantasy
Quicksilver
- Romantasy
House of Flame and Shadow
- Mystery / Thriller
We Are All Guilty Here
- Non-Fiction
1929
- Romantasy
House of Sky and Breath
- Non-Fiction
Abundance
- Romantasy
House of Earth and Blood
- Fantasy
The Tainted Cup
- Science Fiction
1984
- Non-Fiction
The Let Them Theory
No reviews in the latest batch match that cut. Search every review →
From the Archives
Every universe →
The Bestiary of Prythian
A complete field guide to every creature in ACOTAR — the death-gods, the lesser Fae, the war beasts, and the monsters locked inside the Prison.
The Bestiary of Prythian
A complete field guide to every creature in ACOTAR — the death-gods, the lesser Fae, the war beasts, and the monsters locked inside the Prison.
The Dread Trove
The Mask, the Harp, and the Crown — what they are, what they cost, and why they are the most dangerous things in Prythian.
Morrigan: when a name becomes a prophecy
The Phantom Queen of the Night Court — named for a Celtic war goddess and built on five centuries of sealed narratives heading into Book 6.
Eris Vanserra: the monster with a plan
A re-read of the most strategically misunderstood Vanserra — the heir Maas has been quietly positioning for Book 6.
The court system, mapped and explained
A field guide to all seven courts of Prythian — rulers, magic, allegiances, and the political fault lines you need to track.
Elain Archeron: The Sister They Underestimated
A meticulously paced character arc masquerading as peripheral passivity — and the dormant weapon Prythian doesn't see coming.
Book 6 predictions, ranked by emotional damage
Six theories about what Maas is setting up — ranked by how thoroughly they will ruin us if they come true.
The Institute: Red Rising's Brutal War School for Golds
A complete guide to the Institute — the Gold Society's secretive war school. The Houses, the Passage, the war game, and how Darrow broke every rule and won anyway.
The Spark and the Sovereign: The Women Who Made Darrow
One lit the fire. One governed what it left behind. A complete character study of Eo and Virginia au Augustus — the two women who made Darrow.
The 14 Colors of Red Rising, from Gold to Red
Gold rules. Red digs. And twelve Colors fill every role in between. A complete breakdown of all 14 castes of Pierce Brown's Society.
The Augurs: Prophets, Tyrants, and the Darker Truth
Andarra thinks the Augurs were tyrants who got what they deserved. The truth is more complicated — and darker.
Meet the Venerate: All 11 Immortals from The Licanius Trilogy
Eleven immortals, one god pulling their strings for millennia. Who they were, what they did, and how it ended for each of them.
El and Shammaeloth: the dual god deception
The Licanius Trilogy looks like it has two gods. It doesn't. How Shammaeloth used the truth to hide inside the Old Religion for millennia.
More from the Archives
- Lore & World · ACOTAR
The Bestiary of Prythian
- Lore & World · ACOTAR
The Dread Trove
- Character Study · ACOTAR
Morrigan: when a name becomes a prophecy
- Character Study · ACOTAR
Eris Vanserra: the monster with a plan
- Lore & World · ACOTAR
The court system, mapped and explained
- Character Study · ACOTAR
Elain Archeron: The Sister They Underestimated
- Theory · ACOTAR
Book 6 predictions, ranked by emotional damage
- Lore & World · Red Rising
The Institute: Red Rising's Brutal War School for Golds
- Character Study · Red Rising
The Spark and the Sovereign: The Women Who Made Darrow
- Lore & World · Red Rising
The 14 Colors of Red Rising, from Gold to Red
- Character Study · The Licanius Trilogy
The Augurs: Prophets, Tyrants, and the Darker Truth
- Character Study · The Licanius Trilogy
Meet the Venerate: All 11 Immortals from The Licanius Trilogy
- Lore & World · The Licanius Trilogy
El and Shammaeloth: the dual god deception
Discussion Questions
All threads →- The Will of the Many
How does Vis’s hidden trauma shape the way he relates to authority figures like Ulciscor and Veridius—and does that relationship feel like trust, strategy, or something in between?
Weigh in → - Spectacular Things
How did Liz’s ambition for Cricket unfairly penalize Mia?
Weigh in → - An Echo of Things to Come
Is wiping your own memory to escape guilt a cowardly act of avoidance, or a necessary step toward genuine change?
Weigh in → - Yesteryear
Do you believe children of influencer parents have a fundamental right to digital privacy, even if their parents do not recognize it?
Weigh in → - The Keeper
Is justice actually delivered in this book?
Weigh in → - Into the Blue
Do you believe this type of intense, near-telepathic connection exists in real life?
Weigh in →
Join a book club.
Every book reviewed on our site has its own dedicated book club, where members of The Obsidian Library can comment on starter discussion questions or start their own discussion thread. Don't see a book in our library that you want to discuss? Head over to the Book Club page to request a new club. We review requests daily.
Go to the book clubThe Archives, by universe
Character studies, lore breakdowns, and theories for the series that live rent-free in your head.
ACOTAR
- The Bestiary of Prythian NEW Lore & World
- The Dread Trove Lore & World
- Morrigan: when a name becomes a prophecy Character Study
- Eris Vanserra: the monster with a plan Character Study
- The court system, mapped and explained Lore & World
- Elain Archeron: The Sister They Underestimated Character Study
- Book 6 predictions, ranked by emotional damage Theory
From the review desk
Highest-rated books in the Library. Every review contains a content suitability rating, plot summary, major takeaways, related book recommendations, rating out of 5 stars, and discussion questions.
Queen of Faces
All the Colors of the Dark
The Anxious Generation
The Let Them Theory
All the Water in the World
Empire of Storms
Kingdom of Ash
Morning Star
Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow
Project Hail Mary
Golden Son
Restless Stars
The Assassin’s Blade
Sorrow and Starlight
Daisy Jones & The Six
Heartless Sky
Queen of Shadows
The Infinite Game
The Midnight Library
First Lie Wins
Cursed Fates
Fated Throne
Good Inside
Red Rising
No books on the desk match that cut. Search every review →
Can't decide what to read next?
Let the Library pick a highly-rated book for you.
The full collection
Every book we've reviewed, arranged by title. Click a spine to explore.
Browse by section
Fantasy 15 reviews
Epic worlds, hard magic, political intrigue. Sanderson and Islington territory.
Romantasy 23 reviews
High-stakes fantasy with the tension turned all the way up. Maas, Yarros, and company.
Science Fiction 7 reviews
Planetary rebellion, scientific problem-solving, the fight against extinction.
Mystery / Thriller 9 reviews
Cold cases, race-against-time investigations, complicated families.
Non-Fiction 15 reviews
History, psychology, parenting, leadership. Big ideas you can actually use.
Contemporary & Historical 8 reviews
Character-driven stories set in the pulse of today or the halls of history.
Join the Obsidian Library
Joining the Obsidian Library allows you to engage with our virtual book clubs, and provides you access to our monthly newsletter.